facebook  youtube  blogger

The Spiritual Side of Trading: How to Handle Wealth


Some of us dream about wealth. A million dollars could wipe out medical bills that never seem to end after a long illness (I have personal knowledge of this), provide care for aging parents, pay for a home with enough room to breathe, or allow us to quit that dead-end job and pursue a longed-for vocation as a trader — or even take an endless vacation. How wonderful to earn your living while always more or less on vacation — that choice is available to a trader.

In a more charitable vein, we could give to a crisis pregnancy center, or send money to the impoverished people of Haiti. We might even assist the homeless person who pushes a beat-up grocery cart in front of the bank downtown. It would not dissolve all the world's ills, but money could certainly help.

A dream-come-true for one of our trading friends was winning big when he was long a bunch of wheat contracts and rode it from low to all-time high. He did the same thing in gold futures, which just sweetened his fortunes all the more. But prior to those great wins he had lost $4.8 million dollars. He referred to the entire experience as a "hard fall." Another trader I know lost 6.2 million when the market crashed in 1987. He called his experience a "total nightmare." Both of these traders found out that how we view money determines what happens to the dollars that pass through our hands. For Christians, what God says about finances should govern our financial choices, our lifestyle, and our giving.

What does God actually think about money? Does he expect vows of poverty? Is he demanding communal living as in the book of Acts when Christians shared all resources? Does he have a particular fondness for Marxist economic equality, or does he honor a capitalistic system? Does he advocate zero debt, or does he see a place for a certain type of debt? Is he a stickler about giving the first ten percent, and does he promise wealth in return? Are there biblical principles that apply universally to all societies throughout time when it comes to finances? Typical answers to these questions often result in formulistic living. Formulas for following God eventually veer into legalism fueled by fear or presumption.

Our fears cause us to depend on man-made rules for security. Presumption assumes that God is manipulated by our actions. The issue of wealth is no exception. Every aspect of handling money — how we get it, how we go about keeping it, our motivations for giving, and how we can survive financial and emotional fallout when dealing with wealth — is influenced by whether or not we are centered in God. Our approach can be just as flawed as is the process of turning trade winnings into loss.

Getting It

Money is acquired by various means — employment, entrepreneurship, investing, inheriting, gambling, borrowing, selling (think eBay), trading, and so on. For Christians, issues of honesty dictate how we acquire finances. Beyond that, Christians may feel ill at ease with money because wealth is often associated with greed.

A false sense of spirituality through poverty keeps money at arm's length for the wrong reasons. Dave Ramsey, author of Total Money Makeover, states, "There is a negative mind­ set justifying money mediocrity that is maddening. Wealth is not evil, and people who possess it aren't evil by virtue of the wealth.... If you take the stand that managing wealth is evil or carnal, then by default you leave all the wealth to the evil, carnal people."

In Luke 16:9, Jesus instructs us to use wealth: "I tell you, use worldly wealth to gain friends for yourselves, so that when it is gone, you will be welcomed into eternal dwellings." In verse 11 he adds, "So if you have not been trustworthy in handling worldly wealth, who will trust you with true riches?" He states this just before warning us that we cannot serve both God and money (verse 13). Using money as your servant is not the same as becoming a servant to money.

The idea that money equals greed may be related to what Paul Graham calls the "pie fallacy." In his article "How to Make Wealth," Graham explains that those who see wealth in terms of a limited pie think that giving a piece to one person deprives another. This is often true about specific "pots" of money, but not wealth. He supplies an example of restoring an old car: "In doing so you create wealth. The world is — and you specifically are — one pristine old car the richer. And not just in some metaphorical way. If you sell your car, you'll get more for it.... You haven't made anyone else poorer. So there is obviously not a fixed pie."

Once Christians get beyond the pie fallacy, they are able to see wealth as a tool God can use. Instead of believing that the creation of wealth deprives others, generating wealth becomes a means for expanding ministry.

Viewing money solely in terms of "filthy lucre" limits how we obtain finances. For example, it may cause us to view trading or investing as "cheating" or gambling, and keep us from wisely taking advantage of investment opportunities.

Christians hear a mixed message from pulpits, with exhortations about giving alongside implications that money is evil. We cannot give what we should not have to begin with. A consistent biblical view regarding the acquisition of wealth prevents this kind of confusion.

Keeping It

While the two traders mentioned at the beginning of this article had trouble keeping their millions, my friend Arnie (not his real name) did not. After winning $220 million by making excellent trades, the first thing he did was to build a team of financial advisors. Then he studied the lives of others who had had great wealth and then lost it, and examined what went wrong in their experiences. We might think that the larger amount is what kept him out of trouble, but the facts indicate that his financial planning played the significant difference.

  • He sought knowledgeable advice. Arnie recognized that he needed help. Wealth is not something to take lightly. Handling large sums of money is difficult work, and Arnie realized his own inadequacy so he sought the best advice he could find.
  • He did not allow people to manipulate him. Evelyn Adams, who once won millions in the lottery, explains this trap, "Everybody wanted my money. Everybody had their hand out. I never learned one simple word in the English language, 'No.'" In contrast, while Arnie shared some of his winnings, he used financial planning rather than the cries of supposedly needy people to influence his decisions.

  • He recognized the need for expansion. Even with the large sum that Arnie won, he realized that he needed to invest a significant portion. With the rising cost of living and the many traps for money, "keeping it" actually requires expansion. "Saving for a rainy day" sounds like a sound plan, but a savings account is unable to keep pace with inflation, effectively losing money. Some of us may think we have nothing to invest. Mary Hunt, publisher of Cheapskate Monthly, began investing with just $25.

    Fear-based financial advice can pass as "biblical principles." Some Christian advisors place such an emphasis on zero debt and savings that they recommend skimping on items such as cell phones and Internet access — essential tools for today's entrepreneurial market. Once we understand the basics of saving and living within our means, biblical finances should mirror God's creativity.

    In Matthew 25:14-30, there is an interesting parable about a servant who was given charge over a certain amount of money.  When his master returned he said: "I was afraid and went out and hid your talent in the ground." This marks the mentality of a risk-averse trader, investor, or saver. This attempt at "keeping it" produced a rebuke from the master. This is not a license to spend or invest indiscriminately, but a wake-up call to risk wisely on God's behalf. There is more to "keeping" money than simply burying it in a passbook where it is safe. Inflation will eat away at it just as surely as a natural form of erosion.

    Giving It

    "Each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver. And God is able to make all grace abound to you, so that in all things at all times, having all that you need, you will abound in every good work" (2 Corinthians 9:7-8).

    The phrase "under compulsion" is an apt description of legalism. Evelyn Adams felt a compulsion to give to those who had outstretched hands — a major factor in the loss of her wealth. Giving does not mean everybody gets a piece of your pie.

Errors about Christian giving are abundant, from the teaching that if we give money to God, he is obligated to reward us, to the paralyzing fear that God will not supply all our needs if we give to his cause. In contrast to presumptuous and fear-based giving, Dave Ramsey explains the joy of giving. "Giving is probably the most fun you will ever have with money. FUN and recreation is good, but you will tire of golf and travel, and if you eat enough, lobster starts tasting like soap. INVESTING is good, but going around and around that Monopoly board eventually loses its appeal.... Every mentally and spiritually healthy person I've met has been turned on by giving as long as it didn't mean his own lights got cut off."

When we express ourselves creatively through finances as God intended, the act of giving becomes a delight instead of an obligation or a manipulation. There is no set formula to giving. Listening to the Spirit of God will cause us to "purpose in our hearts to give." Mix joy with purpose, and this often translates into giving more than the Old Testament standard of ten percent (Malachi 3:10).

Most of us think of giving as a realm for non-profit organizations. This is certainly true. Ministries would not exist without monetary contributions. Consider also creative alternatives such as for-profit business with a goal to provide jobs and opportunity for the underprivileged. Uniting what is often seen as "secular" business with Spirit-led problem-solving opens fresh doors that provide ongoing benefits for ministries. Generating wealth to help others is one way to partner with God in changing the world. Equipping them to generate their own wealth is an even better way. While wealth is temporal, giving is the way we can "take it with us." Creative giving invests in changed lives, both now and for eternity.

Surviving It

Financial issues are not just about money. They play nasty games with our emotions and create heartache. The Apostle Paul handled both want and wealth with an open hand towards God. "I know what it is to be in need, and I know what it is to have plenty. I have learned the secret of being content in any and every situation, whether well fed or hungry, whether living in plenty or in want." (Philippians 4:12).

Gratitude and contentment are key ingredients to emotional survival. Legalism brings tension, but a biblical view of finances frees us to explore creative ways for God to use money in and through our lives. Avoid a religious sour grapes mentality: "God must know I can't handle wealth. That's why he doesn't give it." As one wannabe trader put it, "Why not ask God to develop qualities in us so that he can trust us with wealth?"

Consider the story of Joseph in the book of Genesis. God used a dungeon experience to prepare him to help save many lives as wealth passed through his hands. Do you see a need around you that tugs at your heart, but it requires finances you don't have? Ask God to teach you what you need to know in order to fill that need.

Unlike many winners whose winnings no longer exist, we can reject the fear and presumption that drive the secular and also the religious world. We can embrace the Creator of creative opportunities. Avoiding pat formulas or paralyzing fears, we look to God himself. Deuteronomy 8:18 states, "But remember the Lord your God, for it is he who gives you the ability to produce wealth." Our walk with God will guide us in the acquisition, investment, and giving of wealth so that we can live eternally knowing that we have employed our finances in expanding the Kingdom.

Derivative transactions, including futures, are complex and carry a high degree of risk. They are intended for sophisticated investors and are not suitable for everyone. There are numerous other factors related to the markets in general or to the implementation of any specific trading program which cannot be fully accounted for in the preparation of hypothetical performance results, and all of which can adversely affect actual trading results. For more information, see the Risk Disclosure Statement for Futures and Options.